The reviews are in. It's not looking good, America.

​

“A POLITICO/Public First poll reveals a growing mismatch between American and international perceptions of the U.S., with allies giving the U.S. low ratings on protecting democracy and dependability. This sentiment is echoed by some of President Trump’s own supporters, highlighting a concerning disconnect.

​

Allies are giving the U.S. one-star and two-star ratings on its efforts to protect democracy and dependability in a crisis.

---

This article is part of an ongoing project from POLITICO and Public First, an independent polling company headquartered in London, to measure public opinion across a broad range of policy areas.

You can find new surveys and analysis each month at politico.com/poll.

Have questions or comments? Ideas for future surveys? Email us at poll@politico.com.

Those who backed former Vice President Kamala Harris, however, offer negative assessments far closer to America’s allies. The results paint a lopsided picture, with Americans — driven by the president’s own supporters — increasingly on an island in how they view the country.

It’s not just The POLITICO Poll that reveals this growing mismatch. Leaders across Europe and Canada are increasingly voicing their concern about Trump’s efforts to upend longtime alliances.

The poll was conducted Feb. 6 to Feb. 9 in the United States, Canada and the three largest economies in Europe: France, Germany and the United Kingdom. We’ve turned the results from several key questions into ratings, comparing answers across countries.

Here’s America, reviewed:“

“The US protects democracy”

U.S. 4.9/10 

About half of Americans, 49 percent, said the U.S. protects democracy, including three in four who backed Trump in 2024. On the contrary, just 35 percent of voters who backed Harris agreed. 

Featured review 

GERMANY 1.8/10 

“I see no need for the Americans to now want to save democracy in Europe. If it would need to be saved, we would manage on our own.” 

—German Chancellor Friedrich Merz 
Dec. 9, 2025

Other reviews 

U.K. 3.4/10 

CANADA 2.5/10 

FRANCE 2.1/10 

Question: “Thinking about the US, do you agree or disagree with the following? The US protects democracy.” 

The U.S. has long seen itself as a defender of democracy — both at home and abroad. But that reputation may be fraying amid growing unease among longtime allies about whether the U.S. still protects the democratic principles it once championed.

When U.S. forces captured Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro earlier this year, Trump pointed to Maduro’s disputed election as part of the rationale for the operation, even as some allies and international experts questioned the legality of Washington’s intervention.

“The US is mostly a force for stability in the world”

U.S. 3.6/10 

A 36 percent plurality of Americans said the U.S. is mostly a force for stability — more than double the share of adults in the other countries who said the same. 

Featured review 

FRANCE 1.5/10 

“We have the Chinese tsunami on the trade front, and we have minute-by-minute instability on the American side. These two crises amount to a profound shock — a rupture for Europeans.” 

— French President Emmanuel Macron 
February, 2026

Other reviews 

U.K. 1.8/10 

CANADA 1.4/10 

GERMANY 1.3/10 

Question: “Which of the following comes closest to your view on the US’s role in the world?” Options: The US is “mostly a force for stability in the world”, “sometimes a force for stability, sometimes a threat,” “mostly a threat to global stability,” “not very important to global stability either way,” or “don’t know.” 

The surveyed nations have been among the hardest hit by Trump’s sweeping trade agenda, resulting in strained economic and diplomatic relationships. The steep levies — and Trump’s repeated broadsides against U.S. allies — have left them doubting Washington’s reliability as both a partner and a stabilizing force.

It’s not just that allies no longer see the United States as a force for stability. Sizable shares, including a 43 percent plurality in Canada, say the country is mostly a threat to global stability.

At the Munich Security Conference last month, a number of global leaders openly questioned the United States’ standing in the international order.

“The US can be depended upon in a crisis”

U.S. 5.7/10 

A 57 percent majority of Americans said the U.S. can be depended on in a crisis, more than double the share of adults in Canada, Germany and France who agree. 

Featured review 

CANADA 2.7/10 

“It is clear that the United States is no longer a reliable partner. It is possible that, with comprehensive negotiations, we will be able to restore some trust, but there will be no turning back.” 

—Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney 
March 28, 2025

Other reviews 

U.K. 3.8/10 

FRANCE 2.7/10 

GERMANY 2.5/10 

Question: “How would you rate The US on the following scales? Can be depended upon in a crisis | Can not be depended upon in a crisis” with the option to choose two levels of agreement on either side or a middle point between the two. The ratings displayed are a sum of the agreement of the levels on either side. 

The most common view among the close allies surveyed, in fact, was that the U.S. cannot be depended on in a crisis. That’s the opinion of a 57 percent majority in Canada, 51 percent majority in Germany, and pluralities in France (47 percent) and the U.K. (42 percent).

Their concerns come as the Trump administration has clashed with allies over defense spending, trade and the scope of collective security agreements. Trump has repeatedly cast doubt over America’s commitments in Europe, fueling questions about whether Washington can be relied upon.

“Has the most advanced technology”

U.S. 5.3/10 

Most Americans — 53 percent — said their country has the most advanced technology in comparison to the European Union and China. But top NATO allies disagree. 

Featured review 

U.K. 3.5/10 

“China is a vital player on the global stage, and it’s vital that we build a more sophisticated relationship. … “Our international partnerships help us deliver the security and prosperity the British people deserve, and that is why I’ve long been clear that the UK and China need a long term, consistent, and comprehensive strategic partnership.” 

— UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer 
January, 2026

Other reviews 

CANADA 3.7/10 

FRANCE 3.6/10 

GERMANY 3/10 

Question: “Comparing China, the EU, and The US, if you had to choose, which would you say…: Has the most advanced technology” with the option to choose China, the EU or the U.S. 

Trump sees the U.S. in close competition with China on technological advancements, repeatedly touting America as the global leader in artificial intelligence and chip production.

But a majority of respondents in the other countries said China, not the United States or the European Union, has the most advanced technology: 54 percent in Canada, 55 percent in Germany, 53 percent in the U.K. and 50 percent in France.

That perception gap could have real-world consequences. If longtime allies view Beijing as the technological leader, it could complicate Trump’s ability to rally partners around policies to try to curb China’s growth.

About the survey

The POLITICO Poll was conducted by Public First from Feb. 6 to 9, surveying 10,289 adults online, with at least 2,000 respondents each from the U.S., Canada, U.K., France and Germany. Results for each country were weighted to be representative on dimensions including age, gender and geography. The overall margin of sampling error is ±2 percentage points for each country. Smaller subgroups have higher margins of error.